The Vikings still can't beat the Colts in an NFL draft tie-breaker (rechecking my work)
So now will the Vikings be in a position to control Andrew Luck’s destiny?
Yes, of course -- if the suddenly hot Indianapolis Colts win their finale and Minnesota loses two.
Last week, I described how the Vikings can’t beat Indy for the top draft pick if the teams are tied. The Colts’ win over Houston Thursday makes that tie a reality, so I thought I’d run through the remaining games and show why the tie-breaker frustration is indelible.
Again, the tiebreaker is strength of schedule; because the weaker schedule “wins” the higher pick, you want as few opponent wins as possible. Currently, things look like this:
Indy, 120
Vikes, 127
In the remaining Week 16 games, only four matter to the Colts-Vikes battle. They are games pitting an opponent either team has played once, versus a team they haven’t played.
Here are the four games that could add a win to Indy (with Vikings’ rooting interests in parenthesis):
New England over Miami (Colts played New England)
Kansas City over Oakland (Colts played KC)
Pittsburgh over St. Louis (Indy played Pittsburgh)
Cincinnati over Arizona (Colts played the Bengals)
There are also two that could add a win to Minnesota (and thus the Vikings need their opponents to lose):
Buffalo over Denver (Vikings played Denver)
Cincinnati over Arizona (Vikings played Cardinals)
If the table gets run, Indy picks up four wins, Minnesota none, so:
Indy, 124
Vikes, 127
But there is also the San Diego-Detroit game. The Vikings played the Chargers once and Detroit twice. Best-case is a Chargers win, which could leave it:
Indy, 124
Vikes, 128
However, you also have add an opponent win from the Vikings (hoped-for) loss to Washington:
Indy, 124
Vikings, 129
To close out Week 16, you have to add five wins to Indy and Minnesota from games involving opponents they’ve played the same number of times.
Both #1-chasers pick up a win from Tampa-Carolina and Atlanta-New Orleans. Indy picks up a win from Cleveland-Baltimore and two from Jacksonville Tennessee (division opponents played twice). Minnesota eats one from Oakland-KC and two from Green Bay-Chicago.
That puts the total at:
Indy, 129
Vikings, 134
The final week’s games look like this:
Indy and Minnesota lose to divisional opponents. That adds two wins to each, making the total:
Indy, 131
Vikings, 136
Indy and Minnesota each get six wins from opponents they’ve played the same number of times. Both squads pick up a win from Tampa-Atlanta and Carolina-New Orleans. Indy picks up one from Baltimore-Cincinnati and Pittsburgh-Cleveland. Minnesota picks up one from KC-Denver and San Diego-Oakland. Indy picks up two from Tennessee-Houston, as does Minnesota from Detroit-Green Bay.
So that puts it at:
Indy, 137
Vikings, 142
The leaves us with all the games pitting an Indy or Minnesota opponent versus a team they haven’t played. Indy’s (with Vikings interest):
New England over Buffalo (Indy played the Pats)
KC over Denver (Indy played KC)
Minnesota’s:
Seattle over Arizona (Vikes played the Cards)
Philly over Washington (Minnesota played Washington)
If all four games break right, Indy picks up two wins, Minnesota none, and we end with:
Indy, 139
Vikings, 142
Sadness.
So this week, we are all Shanahan fans, and next week, it’s GO COLTS and GO BEARS. Yes, the last one catches in my throat.
Have a happy holiday season.




